Nancy and Sarah speak with Meghan Daum, the podcaster behind The Unspeakable and author of a great new collection of essays, The Catastrophe Hour. They talk about writing, Charlie Kirk, young people casting around for meaning, and a very eye-raising report in the New York Times about a recent blockbuster memoir about MDMA-assisted recovered memories of violent sexual assault. It raises some questions!
Will this be a tipping point for the publishing industry? We discuss integrity, celebrity, Oprah Winfrey, the challenge of selling books, and how to fact-check memories in the first place.
Also discussed:
Tylenol: Latest tool of the Resistance
Are Reddit posts the new sad girl diaries?
That time Meghan observed Turning Point gatherings …
The return of Alex P. Keaton!
Books usually don’t have fact-checkers
Sarah’s hard lessons when editing personal essays
Incoherence, the theme of our time
Fabulists in the memoir genre like moths to a flame
Toot’n Totum!
“Nancy is Marie Antoinette.”
The 90s are back, and if you invite us to your party, we will totally stand around the kitchen smoking clove cigarettes
“Monchhichi, monchhichi, oh so soft and cuddly”
The truth vs. my truth
How is Meghan’s new book like a handgun?
Paul Newman used French eye drops?
NYT reader comments FTW
Plus, the John Brown Gun Club, a tragic story of literary shame, more Robert Reford love, and much more!

Listen to this episode with a 7-day free trial
Subscribe to Smoke 'Em If You Got 'Em Podcast to listen to this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.











